As a disclaimer, I am a registered Democrat, so what will follow is defense from a person whose ox will surely be gored. However, if small "d" democracy is about anything, surely fairness is high on the list.
John Deeth, who I consider to be a friend and ally, wrote in his blog that "[Ralph]Nader and [Cynthia] McKinney are expected to draw votes away from Barack Obama, while [Bob]Barr is expected to take votes from John McCain."
I don't disagree with John's assessment, but I do disagree with the presumption that Democrats and Republicans should be automatically given the benefit of being the one's that votes are being "taken" from. As it stands, the major parties already have a distinct advantage over any other candidate (tell me where on the Iowa tax form anyone can check off a box to make a donation to a third party?), plus election rules favor the two parties.
It seems to me that if anyone's votes are being taken, it would be these lesser known candidates. If the $$$ playing field were level, does anyone honestly believe that the plurality of the vote would go to any one party? It is interesting to me that anyone who is not brand D or brand R is often labeled as obstructionist (not by John, of course) to one or the other major party's chances for election. The fact is that the two major parties do not cover the gamut of ideas that people would like to see enacted and these third party and independent candidates offer those ideas.
Having said this, the result of third party candidates and independents on elections, as the game is currently played, is they can sometimes have an effect on the outcome. It seems to me that if the Big Two want to put the threat these candidates pose to rest, their candidates should do what they do to members of their own parties while campaigning for their party nomination; usurp the good ideas. It seems like a "win-win" proposition.
Showing posts with label Fair Elections. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fair Elections. Show all posts
Monday, July 28
Monday, March 3
Putin-Lite Wins In a Pre-ordained Landslide
Russia had its election and as expected, Dmitry Medvedev is the new President.
Truthout has the full story:
Dmitry Medvedev, President Vladimir Putin's hand-picked successor, won a landslide victory in Russia's presidential polls, preliminary results showed on Monday, as critics charged the vote was rigged.
Medvedev won 70.2 percent of the vote based on results from 98 percent of the country's polling stations, the election commission said.
As results rolled in, Putin and Medvedev celebrated at a rock concert on Red Square in scenes broadcast repeatedly on national television.
"Together we can continue the course set by President Putin.... Together we'll go further. Together we'll win. Hurrah!" Medvedev, dressed in jeans and a leather jacket, told a crowd of supporters beneath driving sleet.
Medvedev, 42, also offered assurances that he would be his own man, including in foreign policy, despite his promise to appoint Putin prime minister.
He said there were no plans to change the president and the prime minister's powers, while "foreign policy, according to the constitution, is determined by the president."
However even before voting began foreign observers had criticised the unfair conditions in which the election was held, with Medvedev given blanket media coverage and liberal opponents prevented from registering.
Both the Communist Party and independent vote-monitoring organisation Golos alleged large-scale violations on voting day.
The only Western observer group not to have boycotted the polls, a group from the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, was to give an assessment on Monday, having already described the choice on offer as "limited at best."
Truthout has the full story:
Dmitry Medvedev, President Vladimir Putin's hand-picked successor, won a landslide victory in Russia's presidential polls, preliminary results showed on Monday, as critics charged the vote was rigged.
Medvedev won 70.2 percent of the vote based on results from 98 percent of the country's polling stations, the election commission said.
As results rolled in, Putin and Medvedev celebrated at a rock concert on Red Square in scenes broadcast repeatedly on national television.
"Together we can continue the course set by President Putin.... Together we'll go further. Together we'll win. Hurrah!" Medvedev, dressed in jeans and a leather jacket, told a crowd of supporters beneath driving sleet.
Medvedev, 42, also offered assurances that he would be his own man, including in foreign policy, despite his promise to appoint Putin prime minister.
He said there were no plans to change the president and the prime minister's powers, while "foreign policy, according to the constitution, is determined by the president."
However even before voting began foreign observers had criticised the unfair conditions in which the election was held, with Medvedev given blanket media coverage and liberal opponents prevented from registering.
Both the Communist Party and independent vote-monitoring organisation Golos alleged large-scale violations on voting day.
The only Western observer group not to have boycotted the polls, a group from the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, was to give an assessment on Monday, having already described the choice on offer as "limited at best."
Saturday, February 16
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)